That Sik Luv review — Jescie Hall (spice level, tropes & is it worth it)
that sik luv by jescie hall is a lights-off, blanket-nearby kind of book. and i mean that in the best and most unsettling way possible.
if you’re looking for something dark but still safe… this isn’t it.
this is the kind of book where you’re reading and at some point you just sit there like… okay.
and then keep going anyway.
review
no spoilers edition
verdict
she's spent her life believing she knows what's right, what's wrong, and what truth looks like. then she meets someone who forces her to question everything. a man carrying his own devastating history with the church, his own trauma, and enough darkness to match hers. this book is messy, painful, provocative, and absolutely not for everyone. but if you like dark romance that digs into difficult topics instead of simply using them for shock value, sik luv is one you won't forget anytime soon.
vibe
this book is not for the faint of heart. seriously. if you're looking for a dark romance recommendation and somebody hands you sik luv, understand that they're not easing you into the genre. they're throwing you directly into the deep end and wishing you luck. it's dark, twisted, uncomfortable at times, and constantly pushing at the boundaries of faith, guilt, desire, and morality. this is the kind of book that has you staring at the wall after certain chapters wondering what exactly you just read.
spice
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶 — one of the spiciest books i've read. sexuality is a major part of the story, and the book explores it in ways that are often uncomfortable, complicated, and deeply tied to the characters' trauma and healing.
“She’s my obsession, but more so, she’s my fucking existence. The only point of destruction I crave.”
That Sik Luv by Jescie Hall
reader fit
you like your dark romance genuinely dark. if morally black characters, religious themes, taboo topics, obsession, and stories that force you outside your comfort zone sound appealing, this might be exactly what you're looking for.
you're new to dark romance or prefer your romances lighter. this book tackles some incredibly heavy subject matter and doesn't shy away from making the reader uncomfortable.
content warnings
please check trigger warnings before reading. religious trauma, sexual assault, child abuse, rape, manipulation, mental health struggles, explicit sexual content.
standalone + hea
standalone dark romance with a happily ever after.
what you’ll find in this book
this leans fully into obsession.
not “he really likes her” — more like he’s already decided she’s his and nothing about that is changing.
the tension isn’t playful. it’s constant and unyielding.
it’s the kind of sensation where everything feels a little off, a little wrong… but also impossible to look away from.
and that’s what carries the entire book.
my take
if he’s not already a problem before they even touch… i don’t want it.
the book
That Sik Luv
a dangerously obsessive man becomes the voice of every forbidden desire she’s been taught to bury… and he won’t stop until she gives in.
spice level breakdown
spice rating: 5/5
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶
this is spicy — but not in a light way.
it’s not flirt, build, payoff.
it’s tension, control, and crossing lines that you probably shouldn’t.
the kind where the spice feels tied to the dynamic, not separate from it.
it leans more intense than fun.
tropes in that sik luv
- obsessive mmc
- psychological tension
- taboo dynamics
- stalker vibes
- touch her and die
same energy, different obsession
Haunting Adeline
stalker romance
she can manipulate anyone… except the man who’s been watching her long enough to make her his anyway.
Under Your Scars
billionaire romance
a serial killer meets the one girl who sees something human in him… and decides she’s his, even if loving him destroys her.
Little Stranger
forbidden love
after she sends him to prison, the man who’s been obsessed with her for years comes back ready to take everything… including her.
final thoughts
this is one of those books that you don’t casually recommend.
not because it’s bad — because it’s a lot.
it knows exactly what it is and doesn’t try to soften it or make it easier to digest.
and if that works for you… it really works.
want more like this? say less.
the full romance library is waiting.
peek inside the society library
take me to the library →morally gray men, slow burns, hockey romances, villains who should absolutely not be attractive… it’s all there.
frequently asked questions
is that sik luv worth reading?
how spicy is that sik luv?
is that sik luv a dark romance?
is that sik luv on kindle unlimited?
what tropes are in that sik luv?
join the newsletter
morally gray men delivered to your inbox every sunday.
join the smut & sentiment society
every sunday we send a carefully curated romance recommendation — morally gray men delivered straight to you
continue exploring