When We Had Forever review — Shaylin Gandhi (spice level, tropes & is it worth it)

when we had forever is one of those books that quietly gets under your skin.

“you’re my star. my one in seven billion.”

i rolled my eyes.

then immediately wished someone would say it to me.

this is grief, mystery, forbidden love, and a slow burn that keeps making you think you’ve figured everything out before pulling the rug out from under you.

is when we had forever worth it?

yes.

especially if you’re looking for a romance that’s doing more than just telling a love story.

this book kept surprising me.

every time i thought i knew where it was going, something shifted. and because the mystery is woven into the romance, i genuinely couldn’t stop reading.

if you’re looking for lots of spice, this probably isn’t your book.

if you want a romance with heart, twists, and characters you’ll keep thinking about after you finish, i’d absolutely recommend it.

the book

spice level breakdown

spice rating: 2 / 5

🌶️🌶️

this isn’t a heavy spice book by any means.

it’s emotional.

the mystery makes the romance takes its time, and honestly i don’t think the story would’ve worked any other way.

tropes in when we had forever

• forbidden love
• slow burn
• grief and healing
• mystery romance
• dual timeline
• widowed fmc

what to read after when we had forever

if you loved the slow burn, browse my favorite slow burn romances.

if it was the emotional side that got you, i’d recommend binding 13 next.

if you’re looking for another romance that balances love with a bigger story, between love and loathing is another great pick.

→ slow burn romances

→ contemporary romance books

favorite quote

“The truth is, I’m so in love with you I don’t know what to do. I’m so fucking in love with you it hurts.”

when we had forever spicy chapters

this one is much more about the story than the spice.

you’re here for the emotions.

final thoughts

i love books that make me rethink everything i thought i knew.

this book did exactly that.

it starts as one story.

it slowly becomes another.

and by the end i found myself wanting to immediately go back and reread the beginning.

those are usually the books that stick with me.

want more like this? say less.

the full romance library is waiting.

morally gray men, slow burns, hockey romances, villains who should absolutely not be attractive… it’s all there.

frequently asked questions

is when we had forever worth reading?⌄

yes. if you love emotional romance, slow burns, forbidden love, and a story with something deeper running under the surface, this one delivers.

how spicy is when we had forever?⌄

🌶🌶 — this leans emotional over explicit. the story is the focus, and it’s stronger because of it.

what are the tropes in when we had forever?⌄

forbidden love, slow burn, grief and healing, mystery romance, dual timeline, and widowed fmc.

is when we had forever on kindle unlimited?⌄

yes – as of now it is on kindle unlimited.

what should i read after when we had forever?⌄

for another emotional slow burn, go for binding 13. if you want romance layered with a bigger plot, between love and loathing is a good next step.

join the newsletter